Club Touareg Forum banner
81 - 100 of 121 Posts
Discussion starter · #87 ·
No you haven't...you're a teenager who thinks oversteering is akin to drifting. You have no idea what you're talking about when it comes to handling dynamics and you make that more and more clear every time you make a statement.

So I'll slip outside in a bit, Spin out my touareg in the snow for you (I'll barely touch the steering wheel) and if you don't have 100 in my paypal account, I'll ban you from this site for trolling.
I'm 33 years old. I learned my handling dynamics on a track in my 911 - one that has no airbags, no power steering, no ABS. Just a gas pedal, a steering wheel, and a gearbox. Where did you learn your proper driving technique? There is a giant difference between inducing oversteer for the sake of having fun, and chassis dynamics inducing oversteer for you in specific instances. When people (outside of this forum) talk about whether a car oversteers or understeers, they're not going out to a wet lawn or snowy parking lot to see if they can get the back end to come around. They're exiting the apex on a track in WOT and seeing what happens. They're measuring that on a 300 ft skid pad with even throttle inputs to see which end looses traction first. Somehow - this is what is common knowledge in just about every auto arena outside this forum. But, coming here and people seem to think this car oversteers easily, like it's an S2000. If you want to know what easy oversteer feels like, that's the car to drive.

If you think oversteering in the snow means the same thing as oversteer as a result of chassis setup - you should ban yourself from this site.

Here is some light reading for you. Nowhere in this book, or any book, or any auto engineering circle will you find people out spinning their cars in the snow to see if the chassis is setup correctly. They might use snow, rain, dirt roads, etc to calibrate the ESP, but they're not adjusting sway bar sizes and spring rates because the back end comes around easily in the snow.

Chassis Engineering - Herb Adams - Google Books

I love the treg. It has near perfect weight distribution and a super stiff chassis. Combine that with a well dialed damper setup, and it feels really planted at any speed. Aside from the overly boosted and zero feedback steering, I would say it's a marvel that this car handles as good as it does. But, it has no LSD diff in the rear, soft sways (you could put stiffer ones on, but that would detract from off-road comfort), 50/50 power distribution, not enough rubber, not enough power, and it weighs 5500 lbs. The cayenne turbo has 40/60 power distribution, stiffer sways, more rubber, and this results in almost twice the power at the rear axle. Have you driven one? It honestly defies physics, and you need to be brave to get it to properly oversteer at the track. Even in an autocross situation, it's hard to get it to oversteer. Ever done one of those? Most of the cayenne guys would say the chassis understeers, and people have updated sways to try and dial that out a bit. The only real way to really get it setup is to change out the air suspension for coils so you can dial in the spring rates and damper setups (which some have done).

Here is a vid of a B5 S4 OG (Cole) auto crossing his cayenne out here in Colorado. Basically a stock suspension setup. What do you see here? Understeer. At no point does the back end rotate. And, you definitely want some rotation when auto crossing. There is a reason that most high performance AWD cars have more rear power bias than 40/60, and that's because it's really really hard to not have a car understeer when the front is tugging just as hard as the back. Look at how much tech the GTR has in order to make that AWD monster have almost perfect handling characteristics.


If your touareg oversteers, that's not because the touareg itself is setup for oversteer, that's because of the driver. If you're trying to get it to oversteer - then good job. You've accomplished it. If you're not trying to get it to oversteer, but it does (exiting a corner or carrying speed through a corner without braking or accelerating), then that's because of poor driving technique. When you drive something this heavy, you need to have some serious fines in your braking and turn-in technique because you're shifting around so much mass. You can't just jerk it into a corner like you could a lightweight car. It needs to be buttery smooth turn in. If you turn in real fast, the back end feels like it's stepping out, but it just gets back in line after the weight transfer settle down. I've *never* exited a corner, went WOT, and felt the back end come around. You can easily use that weight transfer to your advantage if you want it to oversteer, but if you drive it like it was meant to be driven, and what would result in the fastest line, and it's going to understeer.

I'm done. When the moderator starts making this personal by incorrectly speculating on my age - I know I'm having the wrong conversation with the wrong group of people.
 
I suppose the stig is just kicking out the back end out of boredom?

You did put $100 on the line for anyone that posted a video of oversteer, and I put up a great example of the Stig doing it around a track...as for the $100 I asked you to pay it to the charity of choice and I would match it.

So I supposed this means you're backing out of your own bet.
 
You lost all credibility when you said your meaning of oversteer is when, "the back swaps place with the front".

A skilled driver can use oversteer to his advantage and will not let the vehicle spin out during oversteer. You need to learn to drive if you indeed believe what you said.
.
 
Now, now gentlemen. Please just agree to disagree and let's move on. No need to debate this any further. Clearly there is enough passion about knowledge on this matter to haggle over it and defend it. Nothing wrong with that, but at the end of the day, each of our cars will understeer or oversteer (or sprout fins and take to water) based on the condition it's challenged with (snow, rain, ice, hail, monsoon, tornado, hurricane) and what we each do with our respective PSIs.

*handing both debators a cool drink!
 
Discussion starter · #92 ·
Oversteer shown at the 20 second, 55 sec and 1:26 mark...real kickout at the 1:26...the rear kicking out at 20 seconds is what it will do almost always.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=inXxoVXhCok
Is this the video you're talking about? This isn't real - it's a video game. This is the only video I see of a stig in a touareg on this thread. I guess I thought you were kidding when you posted this......
 
Hi, should we re-title this thread?

Anyway, after doing some research and studying how my Touareg handles, it is my opinion that all of you are right and all are wrong.

Touaregs only display under steer; false.

Touaregs only display over steer; false.

The way my Touareg is set up, and due to my driving style, seems to exhibit more of a tendency to over steer than under steer. Can I make it under steer, absolutely under the right road condition, steering angle, and power output. Yes with ESP on. I only notice electronic intervention when I see the traction symbol on the dash. Mine is last gen T2, so it is possible the clutch pack in the centre diff is being manipulated to provide more power to the rear wheels to aid in over steer.

One of my fav on ramps is a tight RH constant radius uphill curves. It is sort of a classic slow in, fast out curve. As described many times on the net, I experience slight under steer as I start my turn in, no late braking, neutral handling as I approach the apex under maintaining power, and over steer as I increase power from apex to exit. I have nearly managed a 4 wheel drift on the exit of this curve every time with a yaw of the vehicle more to the right indicating over steer on the exit.

This is what I experience with MY Touareg!! Your results may vary.

I have raced cars on dirt ovals. I have been racing motorcycle for several years now. 2 wheelers can exhibit under and over steer as well. Last summer I did a 161mph lap my first time at Daytona Speedway and first time in a professional stock car!! These cars exhibit extreme over steer to the left!! The amount of counter steer to the right to keep the car straight was truly surprising!!

If I get a chance, I will do more testing with ESP off.

Cheers everyone!! Keep your sticks on the ice!! Lol :)
 
The way my Touareg is set up, and due to my driving style, seems to exhibit more of a tendency to over steer than under steer. Can I make it under steer, absolutely under the right road condition, steering angle, and power output. Yes with ESP on. I only notice electronic intervention when I see the traction symbol on the dash. Mine is last gen T2, so it is possible the clutch pack in the centre diff is being manipulated to provide more power to the rear wheels to aid in over steer. One of my fav on ramps is a tight RH constant radius uphill curves. It is sort of a classic slow in, fast out curve. As described many times on the net, I experience slight under steer as I start my turn in, no late braking, neutral handling as I approach the apex under maintaining power, and over steer as I increase power from apex to exit. I have nearly managed a 4 wheel drift on the exit of this curve every time with a yaw of the vehicle more to the right indicating over steer on the exit. This is what I experience with MY Touareg!! Your results may vary. )
I experience the same handling characteristics in my T2 V8 but am able to drift out of a hairpin turn in tiptronic at higher RPM.

I wish I still had access to a private airfield, I would drift on the Tarmac and have someone videotape it and collect $100 from Wrinkledpants.
.
 
I suppose the stig is just kicking out the back end out of boredom? You did put $100 on the line for anyone that posted a video of oversteer, and I put up a great example of the Stig doing it around a track...as for the $100 I asked you to pay it to the charity of choice and I would match it. So I supposed this means you're backing out of your own bet.
If you're talking about the R50 on the track I hope you understand how an experienced driver can induce oversteer even though in the clip you can see (if you look carefully) incidences of understeering (when he exits corners way wider from the optimal line)...
 
Wait, what's the torque split of the R50?

Any car would understeer/oversteer if you go past its traction limits. It's just physics. Don't matter what goodies you have underneath your car, or what shoes it's on.

The faster you go and the later you brake, the closer you get to the limit. And that's where the fun starts.

Cheers!
 
That R5O vid is a Xbox game, you cant believe everything you see, latest games are very realistic. Its a replay of a persons lap.
Yup just playing along. Was so entertained by the exchange of expertise here that I want this thread to be the longest in this forum's history, that's why I had to write something \m/
 
Well, my bad about the R50 video game clip. I just couldn't see why would Nick threw in a clip of a simulation to support his arguments. I didn't sense he was joking when he was arguing against Wrinkledpants thesis. And Mr Phoenix intelligence is definitely something YOU can't measure, if you know what I mean...
 
81 - 100 of 121 Posts