Hi, I am original owner of early VIN # 04 V8 and just came back from the dealer. He quoted $1740 to replace Right Rear drive shaft propeller. The described noise only became noticeable during the recent cold snap over the holidays. VWNA is challenging a power train warranty repair as I just crossed over at 60,130 miles. I am 1050 miles from home and not sure whether to risk the trip, add the miles or have it done locally. Any experience as to how long you can live with this noise before more damage is done? Any precedence as to how much tolerance VWNA gives on mileage? Any negotiating hints?
Normally I keep every receipt, but the morning after I picked my car up from having the driveshaft and bearing/seal replaced, I was hit by a falling tree limb while driving to work. Some would say bad timing, but the car saved my life. I seem to have misplaced that receipt - it was most likely still in the car and with all the broken glass you can imagine what happened. Anyway, typically my warranty work only shows the # of hours billed to VW with no part prices. So I can't comment for sure on cost...but my recollection is they said parts were about $400, plus labor. However, you say right rear drive prop, which I believe is after the rear differential whereas mine was ahead of the rear differential (Same problem - i.e., drive shaft seal issue).
I only put about 150 miles on my car from time I first heard it until replaced. Not sure if I would put the mileage (1000+) on to get it home. Based on the fact you are over 1000 miles from home and only 130 miles out of warranty, I would claim the problem happened en-route and you were in no position to stop immediately. Fix the car where it is, and tell them you expect to be treated fairly. Unlikely, the dealer would try to overcharge you knowing that your not going to roll over like a sheep to slaughter on the car being 130 miles out of warranty. VW's reputation isn't the best, but you never know. Chrysler paid 50% of transmission problem on a Jeep Grand Cherokee I owned with the car 2k miles out of warranty. The service advisor kind of slipped when he said "We see a lot of this problem." I think VW has seen a fair amount of this. Appeal to their good nature about taking care of a customer, because if they don't it will cost them more in the long run. Given the cost, if they refuse, tell them you'll see them in arbitration. Worth a try. Good luck.