Are you still under factory warranty on both?
$2k on the VW Fidelity warranty is a good price. You might be able to get a little lower if you want to work for it but might not be worth the effort. One of the best features of this warranty is all VW dealers must honor it. While technically a third-party warranty, it is the only one that is VW branded, thus the reason all dealers must honor it.They are both still under warranty. My wifes 2014 gets about 12,000 miles a year. mine gets about 20,000 a year and will quickly run out. I was quoted $2000 for a 100000 mile bumper to bumper. I had a MDX, the head light went bad and cost almost $2000 to fix. Not sure how long I will keep the cars with what will happen with all this emissions scandal fall out.