rso2011, I see your in Seattle, try campbell/nelson in north seattle. They fixed mine and so far it seems to be working. Remember, this is a service bulletin not a full recall so it allows VWoA to say nothing is wrong were just straitening things up a little. You know recall is a 4 letter word in the auto industry. anyway try them, they have the full 411 on the subject and seem to be very pleasent to work with, which in VW circles is amazing.
As for the rope caulking I was told, but did'nt need to use it. But to put a string of rope caulk up half way up one side across the front and half way down the other up under the leading edge of the rain tray where the tray meets the bottom of the roof sheet metal. This was info gathered from other VWoA areas (NOT!) Campbell/Nelson VW.
Good Luck, try the dealer first, then if all else fails, try yourself.