A Cole Notes version of their “defence” was as follows
VW-this case needs to be thrown out because there’s nothing wrong with the vehicle.
(8 work orders proving otherwise including one from days before the hearing with CEL flashing and tech acknowledging rough idle/ loss of power etc. )
VW-ok there’s something wrong with it, but he has a warranty and if he brings it in we will fix it
(Judge says isn’t 8 times into the dealer more than reasonable)
VW-we have a fix in the works for the computer
(I got the fix the week before and it didn’t fix anything as acknowledged by a work order, I then say there’s others here that have the same issue)
VW- as per the defendant’s statement of there being an issue with more Touaregs than his own. We move to dismiss this hearing because this court is for individuals with issues to their vehicle only, this sounds like a larger problem that would be more suited to a class action situation!
(Judge laughs, you just told me there’s nothing wrong with his vehicle, then you admit there might be, now you’re saying there’s an issue with all the touaregs?! “What you just said makes me think a lot less of volkswagen as a company”
VW- we close the case with the fact he has a warranty and he should bring it in and we will fix it.
( a few days later I got a letter saying I won and will be awarded full purchase price less usage)
I barely had to say anything in the hearing, VW sank themselves.